May 27, 2024


The business lovers

Medicare Advantage, consolidation drove healthcare insurer trends in 2021

Photograph: FG Trade/Getty Pictures

It was hard to predict development traces for the payer and well being coverage marketplace in 2021, largely due to the fact of persistent uncertainties because of to the COVID-19 pandemic. Customer conduct has turn out to be extra unpredictable, treatment types and choices are shifting and payers are adapting to a earth which is evolving fast and in unexpected means.

One particular element that has been rendered really unpredictable by the virus is the economical well being of the nation’s main insurers, which soared in the course of the preliminary waves of the pandemic in 2020 but then settled again down to earth toward the conclude of that yr. In 2021, insurers nevertheless posted mostly significant earnings, but they ended up much from the heights seen the previous yr.

About the class of the yr a several basic themes commenced to emerge. Insurers are plowing forward with digital transformation initiatives, including the enlargement of telehealth and digital well being. Synthetic intelligence and equipment finding out have labored their way into the combine and 50 percent of payers now have innovation labs in the perception that digital innovation will be the essential to the long run.

Insurers also ongoing to consolidate in 2021, ensuing in really concentrated marketplaces that have drawn the notice of the federal govt, which seeks to curb consolidation in a bid to empower shoppers.

And then there’s Medicare Edge, which carries on to mature it’s approximated MA ideas will include extra individuals in 2022 than first Medicare. A number of main insurers have taken recognize, expanding their MA choices in an effort and hard work to capture extra of the sector.

It is been a wildly various yr in the payer room, but the way it has performed out implies quite a few of these development traces may well proceed into 2022 … and outside of.


COVID-19 carries on to have an effect on each and every aspect of American daily life and the healthcare marketplace, and it’s driving trends in the payer earth as perfectly. At the HIMSS Condition of Health care occasion in June, Shreesh Tiwari, principal at ZS, explained the coronavirus has led to an boost in payer adoption of technology and innovation.

Sixty-4 percent of well being coverage executives report an accelerated adoption of digital well being initiatives these kinds of as digital well being. Another 53% report an acceleration in adoption of synthetic intelligence and equipment finding out procedures, although forty two% explained COVID-19 has assisted aid the adoption of price-primarily based treatment preparations, according to Condition of Health care research by HIMSS, the mother or father organization of Health care Finance News.

COVID-19 has assisted to push changes not just in technology, but in angle, Tiwari explained. The mental and cultural boundaries in terms of adoption are no longer remaining seen as concerns.

Around 50 percent of payers have an innovation lab and think AI and equipment finding out will push innovation forward. But 53% think healthcare startups will lead the way in driving large technology innovation, Tiwari explained.

The govt also performs a essential job. Forty-6 percent of payers consider current procedures and rules will aid innovation.

“Payers have tasted the fruits of innovation in the previous several months,” Tiwari explained at the time. “Interoperability is remaining seen as a essential driver in terms of handling concerns coming out of the technology infrastructure, facts infrastructure concerns we have, carefully followed by facts privacy and facts protection.”

Not all of insurers’ digital initiatives are going flawlessly, nevertheless. Wellbeing ideas are revamping their digital choices in a bid to make sure you shoppers, but these initiatives are challenging, a Deloitte survey observed in June. A lot of ideas are having difficulties to appropriately prioritize jobs, suggesting a absence of apparent vision.

In simple fact, about 50 percent of the 35 technology leaders surveyed discovered this absence of vision as an impediment to these ongoing digital transformation initiatives. 

Consumers are the kinds largely afflicted, as purchaser-struggling with platforms have made the minimum progress. A tiny above 50 percent of respondents, 57%, explained they’re nevertheless in the method of advancing these courses, although the remainder have not but commenced but say they will do so inside of the future two several years.

There are other parts that are lagging as perfectly. The survey focused on modernization initiatives of five technology platforms – administrative, analytics, scientific, core, shopper support and engagement – and only two respondents explained they experienced modernized a single of these platforms.

Those people surveyed discovered cyber and details protection as the selection two financial investment priority right after business enterprise intelligence. But they warned it could be costly to suitable cyber-related problems, notably kinds having to do with cloud configuration. Baking in cybersecurity in DevOps from the outset could make for a extra efficient and resilient method.

The conclusions speak to the broader dilemma of client engagement, which has been an ongoing situation for well being ideas and insurers. A J.D. Ability 2020 U.S. Industrial Member Wellbeing Prepare analyze observed that sixty% of privately insured U.S. well being prepare members explained they experienced not been contacted by their well being prepare with steering or details related to COVID-19, and approximately 50 percent (forty eight%) explained their well being prepare has not proven worry for their well being considering the fact that the pandemic began.

Wellbeing ideas have not acquired shopper centricity, as just 36% of professional well being prepare members explained their well being prepare functions in their most effective curiosity “constantly” or “most of the time,” and just 25% explained they view their well being prepare as a trusted associate in their well being and wellness.

This absence of shopper-centric positioning resulted in an general gratification score final yr for professional well being ideas of 719 on a one,000-stage scale, among the least expensive of all industries evaluated, according to J.D. Ability.


Medicare Edge enrollment ongoing to boost and quite a few main insurers expanded their MA footprints. It is turn out to be a hot sector for insurers heading into the new yr.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Providers explained that in 2022, MA is projected to access 29.five million individuals in comparison to 26.nine million enrolled in a Medicare Edge prepare in 2021. 

For quite a few seniors, MA is the favored well being coverage due to the fact of its lower upfront month-to-month costs and additional gains. Medicare Edge ideas will proceed to supply a huge array of supplemental gains in 2022, including eyewear, hearing aids, each preventive and detailed dental gains, entry to meals (for a confined length), above-the-counter things, conditioning gains and all over the world unexpected emergency/urgent protection. 

In addition, the percentage of ideas providing unique supplemental gains for chronically sick people will boost from 19% to 25%.

An increasing selection of Medicare Edge twin suitable unique wants ideas include each Medicare and Medicaid companies for individuals who are dually suitable. In 2022, 295 ideas (in comparison to 256 in 2021), will include all Medicare companies, as well as Medicaid-coated behavioral well being treatment method or extended-expression companies.

CMS will proceed to test the Element D Senior Cost savings Product for insulin for seniors in extra than two,one hundred ideas in 2022. This yr, above five hundred new Medicare Edge and Element D prescription drug ideas, as perfectly as two new pharmaceutical companies of insulin, are joining the product that minimizes out-of-pocket paying out.

In addition, extra than one,000 Medicare Edge ideas will participate in the CMS Innovation Center’s Medicare Edge Price-Based mostly Coverage Design Product in 2022, which checks the effect of providing a projected million individuals personalized gains intended to far better handle their illnesses and handle social wants from food stuff insecurity to social isolation. 

The VBID Model’s Hospice Reward Part, now in its 2nd yr, will also be supplied by one hundred fifteen Medicare Edge ideas in portions of 22 states and U.S. territories. It presents enrollees improved entry to palliative and integrated hospice treatment. 

To assistance with their Medicare costs, lower-money seniors and grown ups with disabilities may well qualify to receive economical guidance from the Medicare Cost savings Plans. Only about 50 percent of suitable individuals are enrolled, CMS explained.

Cigna is obtaining on on the act by expanding its MA ideas, increasing into 108 new counties and three new states – Connecticut, Oregon and Washington – which will boost its geographic existence by approximately thirty%, the insurer explained in Oct.

As part of the enlargement, Cigna explained most current consumers will shell out the exact or lessen premiums, and promised that each and every sector will have at minimum a single $ premium prepare. Other gains will consist of a social relationship method to overcome loneliness, personalized ideas for individuals with diabetic issues and incentives for yearly wellness exams and other preventive treatment.

Cigna has improved its geographic existence in MA by eighty% considering the fact that 2019, the insurer explained. The organization now provides ideas in 477 counties throughout 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Centene, in the meantime, explained this yr it will be broadening its access in the Medicare Edge room in 2022, expanding into 327 new counties and three new states: Massachusetts, Nebraska and Oklahoma.

In all, this signifies a 26% enlargement of Centene’s MA footprint, with the providing obtainable to a possible forty eight million beneficiaries throughout 36 states. At this time, Centene serves extra than million MA members throughout 33 states.

In September, Centene also introduced it would consolidate its current Medicare brand names, including Allwell, Wellbeing Net, Fidelis Care, Trillium Edge, ‘Ohana Wellbeing Prepare and TexanPlus, below a single unified manufacturer dubbed Wellcare.

In the meantime, UnitedHealthcare, which presently has significant sector control with its Medicare Edge ideas, will reinforce its foothold in the room by expanding its MA ideas in 2022, introducing a possible million members and reaching 94% of Medicare-suitable shoppers in the U.S.

At this time, extra than seven.3 million individuals are presently enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Edge ideas. The insurer explained the enlargement will concentration on lowering prescription drug costs, and increasing gains and the member encounter.

But although UnitedHealthcare has a significant foothold in the Medicare Edge room, it underwent scrutiny from the federal govt previously this thirty day period, when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Providers blocked 4 Medicare Edge ideas from enrolling new members in 2022 due to the fact they failed to spend the minimal threshold on medical gains. A few UnitedHealthcare ideas and a single Anthem prepare unsuccessful to strike the expected 85% mark three several years in a row.

Medicare Edge ideas are expected to spend a minimal of 85% of premium dollars on medical fees failure to do so for three consecutive several years triggers the sanctions.

For UHC, the penalties utilize to its MA ideas in Arkansas, New Mexico and the Midwest, which encompasses Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa. UHC ideas include about eighty three,000 members, and the Anthem prepare handles about one,two hundred members. They are unable to supply find ideas to members right until 2023, assuming they strike the 85% threshold future yr – what’s named the medical reduction ratio (MLR). If they fail to strike the threshold for five several years in a row, the govt will terminate the contracts.

UHC associates explained to Bloomberg that it missed the 85% benchmark in certain marketplaces in part due to the fact of clients deferring medical treatment because of to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Humana also introduced it would debut a new Medicare Edge PPO prepare in 37 rural counties in North Carolina in response to sector need in the eastern part of the point out. 


Wellbeing insurer consolidation has been a further ongoing development – and a single the current administration would like to see with tighter reigns.

An govt purchase issued by President Joe Biden in July cracked down on healthcare facility and well being coverage consolidations and other actions it explained decreases competition and drives up price ranges. The 4 parts of healthcare specific are: prescription medicines, healthcare facility consolidation, well being coverage consolidations and hearing aids.

Consolidation in the well being coverage marketplace has intended that quite a few shoppers have tiny selection when it comes to selecting insurers, the purchase explained. 

Biden directed the Department of Wellbeing and Human Providers to standardize prepare choices in the well being coverage marketplace so individuals can comparison store extra very easily. Plans supplied on the exchanges are challenging by the a variety of companies supplied and discrepancies in deductibles, the purchase explained.

Rick Pollack, president and CEO of the American Healthcare facility Association, urged federal agencies at the time to concentration on procedures that handle competition among professional well being insurers.

“In simple fact, with professional well being coverage ideas, approximately three out of 4 marketplaces ended up really concentrated in 2019 and the prime five biggest insurers by itself control approximately 50% of the sector. Scientific tests have observed that when an coverage sector is really concentrated, insurers reduce service provider payments and do not go savings along to the purchaser.”

The effects of consolidation in 2021 also prolonged to prescription medicines. Consolidation among standalone Medicare Element D prescription drug ideas was the root induce of a 23% decrease in choices for 2022, according to conclusions posted final thirty day period by the Kaiser Loved ones Foundation.

The typical Medicare beneficiary will have a selection of 23 stand-by itself prescription drug ideas (PDPs) in 2022, seven less PDP choices than in 2021, the facts showed. Whilst the selection of PDP choices in 2022 is much lessen than the peak in 2007 – when there ended up fifty six these kinds of choices, on typical – there are nevertheless several standalone drug prepare choices, according to KFF.

The somewhat substantial decrease in the selection of PDPs for 2022 is principally the end result of consolidations of prepare choices sponsored by Cigna and Centene, ensuing in the sector exit of three countrywide PDPs from each agency in each area: all three of Cigna’s Express Scripts PDPs and three of Centene’s 6 Wellcare PDPs. Element D sponsors are confined to providing no extra than three PDPs in each area. 

This accounts for just above two hundred PDPs supplied in 2021 that will no longer be supplied in 2022. Enrollees in these consolidated ideas will be instantly switched to other ideas supplied by the exact prepare sponsor, whilst they can decide on to swap into a various prepare in the course of the yearly open up enrollment interval.

The selection of companies sponsoring stand-by itself drug ideas has declined steadily above time, from extra than forty companies in 2010 and previously several years, dropping below 25 companies commencing in 2015, and at 16 companies in 2022. Which is lessen than in any other yr considering the fact that Element D commenced. 

PDP enrollment is predicted to be concentrated in a small selection of companies in 2022, as it has been each and every yr. Based mostly on August 2021 enrollment, eight out of 10 enrollees in 2022 are projected to be in PDPs operated by just 4 companies: CVS Wellbeing, Centene, UnitedHealth and Humana. All 4 companies supply PDPs in all 34 locations future yr.

Even with these yr-to-yr changes in prepare protection and costs, as perfectly as changes in beneficiaries’ well being wants, a previous KFF analysis observed that most Medicare beneficiaries did not review ideas in the course of a new open up enrollment interval, and most Element D enrollees did not review the protection supplied by their drug prepare to other drug ideas.

The quantities are identical throughout each Medicare Edge and conventional Medicare, with 68% of MA beneficiaries saying they really don’t review medical ideas, and seventy three% of these in conventional Medicare boasting the exact.

Twitter: @JELagasse
Electronic mail the writer: [email protected]